The Insurance Buzz
The Insurance Buzz shares top tips for Insurance Agents on how to maximize their entrepreneurial journey. Sales training tips, mindset, and motivation and learn from some of the best in the industry and experts in the field as they share what they have done to be successful as an Insurance Agent.
The Insurance Buzz
412. The Data War in Insurance: How Brett Bortz Built a $12.8M Book in 2 Years
🎯 Book a 1:1 Agency Coach AI Demo
See exactly how AI can coach your team, grade every conversation, and increase production—without more meetings or micromanagement.
👉 Book your call: HERE
Watch the full episode on YouTube: HERE
What’s in this episode:
In this episode of The Insurance Buzz, Michael and Courtney Weaver sit down with Brett Bortz, a data-obsessed Farmers agent who built a $12.8M book in under two years — without slowing down during one of the toughest markets insurance has seen.
Brett pulls back the curtain on what’s actually happening behind declining close rates, why most agents misread market downturns, and how he uses data, automation, and disciplined lead buying to stay aggressive when others panic.
This is a no-fluff conversation for agency owners who want to control their numbers instead of reacting to them.
[00:00] Why throttling down in a tough market will cost you
[03:00] Brett’s background: Allstate → indie → Farmers
[06:00] How Brett built a $12.8M book in under 2 years
[09:30] What’s driving the market downturn (and why it’s not just you)
[13:00] Brett’s internet lead engine: 700–1,600 leads/day
[17:00] The close ratios Brett actually tracks (lead-to-sale + CPA)
[20:30] Time-to-Sale: why speed matters more than “cheap” leads
[24:00] The automation trap: why follow-up tanks when things get hard
[28:30] What Brett’s data showed when sales dropped July–September
[33:00] Brett’s 2026 plan: reset zip codes, tighten ROI, expand states
[36:30] “Throttle up” mindset: play to win, not to survive
[40:00] Selling part of your book to create cash for the next wave
[42:00] How to connect with Brett + “control your data”
👤 Guest Contact — Brett Bortz
👉 Let Brett know you heard him on The Insurance Buzz
Facebook:https://www.facebook.com/brett.bortz.9
Email: brett@inscendo.com
CRM Platform:https://inscendoiq.com
BOOK A DEMO– Agency Coach AI Learn More: Let's Chat https://agencycoachai.com
The first 24/7 AI sales coaching platform built for insurance pros. Real-time grading, role plays, and coaching that help producers close more deals.
TEXT MICHAEL DIRECTLY
Have a question or want to talk to Michael directly? It’s really him, not a robot. Text “BUZZ” to (816) 727-7610
FREE 7-Day Demo – Weaver Sales Academy
Try it: CLICK HERE
Tools + Free Resources
https://www.weaversa.com
Connect with Michael Online
LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/michaelweaverwsa
YouTube: @michaelweavertraining
Facebook: facebook.com/themichaelweaver
Instagram: @michaelweaver